Skip to content

Bradley Manning’s Trial: Media Coverage & the Conditions for Reporters at Fort Meade

August 7, 2013


On Friday, on KALW’s program, “Your Call,” I appeared with The Guardian‘s Ed Pilkington and former McClatchy Baghdad Bureau correspondent Sahar Issa to discuss Pfc. Bradley Manning’s trial.

The focus was media coverage of the trial and the lack of attention by media to what he revealed along with conditions for press at Fort Meade. There also was a bit of discussion of the verdict itself, which came down one week ago and Issa movingly reported on the current violence in Iraq and shared how she had hoped the trial would rekindle interest in the war crimes Manning revealed, which did not happen.

The following is a transcription of the final five-minute portion of KALW’s 8/1/2013 program “Your Call: The trial of Bradley Manning” which you can listen to in its entirety at the link. [Thanks to my assistant, Jeff Creamer, for transcribing.] 

Rose Aguilar: Ed, what are you thoughts, that this is ‘history’ already? [that the contents of the Manning leaks are regarded as ‘old news’]

Ed Pilkington: I think we have to be careful, not least because I’m thinking of Bradley Manning himself. I mean, bear in mind he might have, who knows, -he might have 30 years in jail to look forward to. Let’s not take away from him what he actually achieved, which is that there was a huge debate. He said he wanted to spark a worldwide debate about the cost of war.

Well, there was a worldwide debate about the cost of war, and it was achieved by Wikileaks. And I know that because we at the Guardian were right at the beginning of it. You know, we approached Wikileaks, we worked with Julian Assange, and we put together an international lineup of newspapers which carried the very first Wikileaks’ disclosures.

And it did have a huge impact; it caused a massive debate around the world. And I think, particularly at a local level, there were debates in Haiti about corruption in Haiti, there were debates in Tunisia and in Egypt which helped to spark the Arab Spring. There were huge debates about the collateral Murder video when it was put out.

And three years on, it’s perhaps not surprising that the [inaudible] has calmed down and they’ve subsided. Although one does still see the databases of information that Manning leaked referred to regularly, they’ve now become a sort of journalist tool that people are still using around the world.

And that’s my second point really, is that the debate has subsided, it’s kind of calmed down, which isn’t surprising three years later. And it points to what’s important about that you need to keep giving the possibility for journalism to do its work: to hold power accountable.

And this is why I think the Manning trial is particularly significant and why the lack of media coverage nationally in America has been regrettable. Because what the Obama administration is definitely trying to do is to make sure there are no future Bradley Mannings. They are trying to use him to cause such a chill over the media that no people will ever do what he did again.

And you look at Edward Snowden, now stuck in Russia for up to a year, which is a country you know I don’t think he would choose naturally to be in. But he is there because he watched what happened to Bradley Manning and he has let it be known that he is fearful that the same treatment would be given to him. So what did he do? He left the country.

I think many other people would do something different; -they would not leak at all. And that is what the Obama administration wants to happen. And therefor there’s a real risk of a chill being put on, particularly investigative journalism, and particularly in the national security area.

Rose Aguilar: Yes, and especially in this information age when you look at how many people have access to such a massive trove of documents. Read more in the dissenter.


From → News

Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s